17 Bakery-Style Frosted Sugar Cookies (Soft & Thick)

Planning your holiday baking? Browse this festive collection for ideas to share, gift, or add to the dessert table. Each recipe name below opens the full recipe with its ingredients and instructions.

  1. Sour Cream Cut-Out Sugar CookiesSour Cream Cut-Out Sugar CookiesSour Cream Cut-Out Sugar Cookies

    Tender sour-cream sugar-cookie cut-outs with smooth tops and gently raised centers.

  2. Buttercream Frosted Sugar CookiesButtercream Frosted Sugar CookiesButtercream Frosted Sugar Cookies

    Puffy sour-cream sugar cookies with a soft cake-like crumb and a generous swirl of vanilla buttercream.

  3. No-Chill Sugar CookiesNo-Chill Sugar CookiesNo-Chill Sugar Cookies

    Thick cream-cheese sugar-cookie cut-outs with soft centers, ready to roll and bake without refrigerator waiting.

  4. Eggnog Sugar CookiesEggnog Sugar CookiesEggnog Sugar Cookies

    Soft eggnog sugar cookies with nutmeg, tender centers and a creamy eggnog frosting.

  5. Fudgy Chocolate Crinkle Cookies with OilFudgy Chocolate Crinkle Cookies with OilFudgy Chocolate Crinkle Cookies with Oil

    Cocoa and miniature chocolate chips give these oil-based crinkles a soft center beneath a double sugar coating.

  6. Soft Sugar CookiesSoft Sugar CookiesSoft Sugar Cookies

    Puffy cream-cheese sugar cookies with a soft, tender crumb and pale vanilla tops.

  7. Chocolate Sugar Cookie BarsChocolate Sugar Cookie BarsChocolate Sugar Cookie Bars

    Soft cocoa sugar-cookie bars with a thin dark-chocolate finish.

  8. Christmas Sugar CookiesChristmas Sugar CookiesChristmas Sugar Cookies

    Soft Christmas sugar cookies with a sparkling red-and-green sugar coating and a creamy vanilla center.

  9. Funfetti Sugar Cookie SandwichesFunfetti Sugar Cookie SandwichesFunfetti Sugar Cookie Sandwiches

    Sprinkle-flecked vanilla sugar cookies paired around soft birthday-style buttercream.

  10. Mango Buttercream Sugar CookiesMango Buttercream Sugar CookiesMango Buttercream Sugar Cookies

    Thick gluten-free sugar cookies with a sunny mango buttercream made from real fruit puree.

  11. Sugar Cookie CakeSugar Cookie CakeSugar Cookie Cake

    A soft 9-inch sugar-cookie cake with rainbow sprinkles, white chocolate chips and a buttercream border.

  12. Sugar Cookie BarsSugar Cookie BarsSugar Cookie Bars

    Soft vanilla sugar-cookie bars with a smooth cream-cheese frosting layer, cut into tidy party-ready squares.

  13. Cinnamon Sugar CookiesCinnamon Sugar CookiesCinnamon Sugar Cookies

    Soft cinnamon-sugar cookies with crinkled tops and a gentle snickerdoodle-style tang from cream of tartar.

  14. Pumpkin Sugar CookiesPumpkin Sugar CookiesPumpkin Sugar Cookies

    Soft pumpkin sugar-cookie cut-outs with real pumpkin puree, warm spices and orange-tinted buttercream ridges.

  15. Almond Flour Sugar CookiesAlmond Flour Sugar CookiesAlmond Flour Sugar Cookies

    Gluten-free almond-flour sugar cookies with crackly sugar tops and a soft nutty crumb.

  16. Kitchen Sink Christmas Cookies with Pretzels and M&MsKitchen Sink Christmas Cookies with Pretzels and M&MsKitchen Sink Christmas Cookies with Pretzels and M&Ms

    Brown-sugar drop cookies combine pretzels, potato chips, two chocolates and red-and-green candy for a sweet-and-salty cookie box addition.

  17. Buttermilk Sugar CookiesButtermilk Sugar CookiesButtermilk Sugar Cookies

    Soft, pale buttermilk sugar-cookie rounds with a tender cakey crumb and a subtle cultured tang.